Mr. Scott pleases,) on those who without his power dare to follow his transgressions. His "exemplar vitiis imitabile" has indeed largely contributed to humble and to corrupt our national taste in poetry. The noble little party proceed on their wanderings in the fourth canto; and in their voyage among the western * islands they touch on all (and many more than all) of the scenes that have been illustrated by the faithful pen of Martin, or the less accurate but inimitably energetic graver of Johnson. select the sketch of Staffa: The shores of Mull on the eastward lay †, And all the group of islets gay That guard famed Staffa round. That Nature's voice might seem to say, "Well hast thou done, frail child of clay! Thy humble powers that stately shrine. Task'd high and hard-but witness mine !". We and so also "merrily, merrily goes the bard," in a succession of merriment, which, like Dogberry's tediousness, he finds it in *Much of the materials for this voyage seem to have been gleaned from the author's own excursions in that direction; which, in the shape of extracts from a MS. journal, contribute greatly to enliven the notes. Apropos of this species of lame and halt versification, which abounds in The Lord of the Isles:' it is transplanted from the "Wallace" of Miss Holford, and had better have been left among the weeds of its native flower-garden. his his heart to bestow wholly and entirely on us, through page after page or wave after wave of his voyage. We could almost be tempted to believe that he was on his return from Skye when he wrote this portion of his poem ;-from Skye, the depositary of the mighty cup of royal Somerled,' as well as of Rorie More's' comparatively modern horn;'-and that, as he says himself of a minstrel who celebrated the hospitalities of Dunvegan-castle in that island, it is pretty plain, that when this tribute of poetical praise was bestowed, the horn of Rorie More had not been inactive.' (See notes to canto second, p. 38.) In the corresponding note to the poetical picture of Staffa in the text, the author disclaims any intention of dwelling upon a wonder so often described, and yet so incapable of being understood by description :' but he proceeds to give a brief outline of the prodigy; and we confess that, to our apprehension, he has clearly made out his case, by proving, if this be a specimen of the descriptions of Staffa, that they are indeed utterly unintelligible. Our readers may be gifted with keener penetration: they will find the passage at the 98th page of the notes; which notes have much entertaining and curious matter in them, but are sadly overloaded with extracts from Barbour's Metrical History of "The Bruce ;" and with other stuff, "perilous stuff" we must call it, of which we heartily wish our tuneful antiquary would "purge his cleansed bosom." We particularly allude to a long and dull quotation from Rymer's Fodera; and to a modernization of a good-for-nothing discovery of the indefatigable' Mr. Ritson, in the shape of an old ballad. Not one reader in a thousand is interested, we believe, in such republications; and we deem the case of that one so truly lamentable, that we regard with a species of compassionate amazement the measures which are here taken to minister to his unhappy distemper. We have, however, " tarried all too long" in our digression from The Lord of the Isles.' Yet that lord himself, selon les règles of Mr. Scott's compositions, being the hero, is not the first person in the poem. The attendant here is always in white muslin, and Tilburina herself in white linen. Still, among the Deutero-proti (or second best) of the author, Lord Ronald holds a respectable rank. He is not so mere a magic-lanthorn figure, once seen in bower and once in field, as Lord Cranstoun; he far exceeds that tame rabbit boiled to rags, without onion or other sauce, De Wilton; and, although he certainly falls infinitely short of that accomplished swimmer, Malcolm Græme, yet he rises proportionably above the red-haired Redmond. Lord Ronald, indeed, bating his intended marriage with one woman while he loves another, is a very noble fellow; and, were he not so totally eclipsed by "The Bruce," he would would have served very well to give a title to any octosyllabic epic, were it even as vigorous and poetical as the present. Nevertheless, it would have been just as proper to call Virgil's divine poem "The Anchiseid," as it is to call this The Lord of the Isles:' to all intents and purposes the aforesaid quarto is, and ought to be, "The Bruce." Moreover, we do not see any reason that should prevent us from entering a protest, while we notice Mr. Scott's inferior heroes, against his secone heroines. In the first place, we totally condemn the practice of ladies in male attire trudging about with gentlemen; and, to be serious on a serious subject, we must earnestly expostulate with a writer of so much genius for countenancing with the dangerous lustre of talent so "low-thoughted" a notion as that of woman not only fully returning with affection the scorn which she experiences from any man, but following that man in a masculine and degraded dress, till his slowly awakened tenderness deigns to give her the fruits of compassion or of repentance rather than of love. We hasten from so odious a subject; hoping that what we have said may be felt (as we are sure it ought to be) in every interested quarter. a Not only is the Edith of this story greatly inferior to the lady Isabel in moral dignity, and in force and feeling of character, but it will be recollected that the reader of "Marmion" was strongly and in spite of himself engaged by pity and every softening sensation in favour of the guilty Constance: a tribute this, assuredly, to the poetical energy of the writer, of no common value: but whether of equal value to the taste and tone of his compositions on ethical points of the highest consequence may admit of a doubt. It is not here our business to recur to the violent and atrocious characters on whom he has generally chosen to fix our chief interest, in his popular and therefore important works: but the situation and circumstances of the heroine of his present poem demanded reprehension; particularly as we cannot help entertaining a sort of undefinable notion that this is almost the latest opportunity which we shall have for pointing out the luminous or the dark passages of the first as well as the last of the minstrels.. -We must return for a moment To Scarba's isle, whose tortured shore * And lonely Colonsay; -Scenes sung by him who sings no more! And mute his tuneful strains; Tortured' shore is a catachresis of no trifling magnitude: but it would be vain to attempt a specification of all these violences of expression. Quench'd Quench'd is his lamp of varied lore, Has Leyden's cold remains !'; and now we must proceed rapidly with our voyagers. Ever the breeze blows merrily, But the galley ploughs no more the sea :* they land on a wild and mountainous coast, which they could not indeed well avoid doing in these regions; and, after some parley concerning their poor mute companion, (in discovering whom to be Edith, we assure our readers we have betrayed no secret that is kept by the poet himself,) Bruce blows his horn, and the following animated scene is introduced from the historical tradition : To land King Robert lightly sprung, And Lennox cheer'd the laggard hounds, When waked that horn the green-wood bounds. In breathless haste with eye on flame,- Fling by his bow, and grasp his sword!". And boys, whose hands scarce brook'd to wield The heavy sword or bossy shield. Men too were there, that bore the scars Impress'd in Albyn's woeful wars, At ; At Falkirk's fierce and fatal fight, Around their King regain'd they press'd, 'Tis morning and the convent bell An aged sister sought the cell And hurriedly she cried, "Haste, gentle Lady.! haste. -? Here |